Eat This Podcast
Talking about anything around food

Fad diets Too good to be true

20 September 2022

Janet Chrzan portraitAtkins. South Beach. Whole30. Zone. Keto. Banting? Yes, Banting. Not the Frederick Banting of Banting & Best, discoverers of insulin, but his distant relative William Banting, author, in 1863, of the self-published Letter on Corpulence, Addressed to the Public. Not the first fad diet by any means — Banting, a prominent London undertaker, had tried a bunch — it is the model, acknowledged and otherwise, for all the high-fat, low carbohydrate diets now so familiar and one of the first to seize the public imagination.

In Anxious Eaters: Why We Fall for Fad Diets, Janet Chrzan and Kima Cargill examine fad diets and the people who follow them as anthropologists might examine foreign cultures. Janet Chrzan helped me understand why people are drawn to fad diets and how they help to soothe, at least temporarily, some of the anxieties that surround food.

Notes

  1. Anxious Eaters: Why We Fall for Fad Diets, by Janet Chrzan and Kima Cargill, is published by Columbia University Press.
  2. Janet Chrzan has a website
  3. William Banting’s Letter on Corpulence, Addressed to the Public is a fascinating light read.
  4. Olivier Bernard’s The life cycle of a fad diet is fun.
  5. Here is the transcript; thanks to the supporters who make this possible.
  6. Slight apologies for the banner photo; inspiration abandoned me.

huffduffer icon   Huffduff it

Filed under: Podcasts
See also:

5 thoughts on Fad diets Too good to be true

  • Eat This Podcast mentioned this post 2 years ago.

    It astonishes me that a fad diet can admonish its followers to “drink the Snake juice” without, apparently, a trace of irony. And that reminds me, whatever happened to oil pulling? Not that I really care.

    eatthispodcast.com/fad-diets/

  • Jeremy Cherfas mentioned this post 2 years ago.

    It astonishes me that a fad diet can admonish its followers to “drink the Snake juice” without, apparently, a trace of irony. And that reminds me, whatever happened to oil pulling? Not that I really care.https://www.eatthispodcast.com/fad-diets/

  • Gordon commented 2 years ago.

    Very insightful show. Really enjoyed it.

  • Jeremy Cherfas mentioned this post 2 years ago.

  • Eat This Podcast mentioned this post 2 years ago.

    The average American starts in on a fad diet four times a year. A quarter give up after two weeks. What are they hoping for?

    Latest episode explores the allure of fad diets with Janet Chrzan, author of Anxious Eaters from @ColumbiaUP

    eatthispodcast.com/fad-diets/

  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Webmentions

    Webmentions allow you to respond on your own site and have that appear here. Your response should include a link to this post. Paste the URL to your post below and your comment will appear here. (Learn More.)

Help Keep the Lights On

Ratings and reviews are great. So is an actual donation.

Elsewhere

There are other places I write and respond.

Our Daily Bread

Our Daily Bread was a series of micro-episodes on the history of wheat and bread, with an episode every day through the month of August 2018.

Posts are in correct chronological order, so you need to scroll to the bottom to find the latest.