Eat This Podcast
Talking about anything around food

Mistaken about mayonnaise — and many other foods Food history and alternative realities

27 March 2017

Who invented mayonnaise? Could boiling down tonnes of cattle concentrate beef’s nutritious qualities? Did lemonade put a halt to the plague in Paris?

Tom Nealon writes about these and (many) other topics in his book Food Fights and Culture Wars, a title that does the contents no favours at all. The obvious temptation is to talk about the book as a feast of food history, a smörgåsbord of tasty treats, some old, some new, all interesting. It is all that and more, not least because it is lavishly illustrated with fascinating images. All in all, a great read, but a hard topic for an episode, because the only thing that really connects all those dots is Tom Nealon himself. We talked a lot, covered a lot of ground and, inevitably, left a lot of things out.

I think I disagree with Tom on at least one thing: cannibalism. I’m just not as persuaded as he is by the evidence, and his argument that if you’re eating “others” from over the mountain, then you’re not really eating people, cuts both ways. What better way to make people seem fundamentally different from “us” than to stress that “they” eat people? But that’s a topic for another episode, I hope.

Notes

  1. Food Fights & Culture Wars is currently riding high in Amazon’s New Releases.
  2. Lots more details on mayonnaise in Tom Nealon’s original account of Salsa Mahonesa and the Seven Years War.
  3. To be honest, I had no idea mayonnaise was a topic of such intense interest, but it is.
    1. Hellmann’s Mayonnaise: A History
    2. A Brief History of Mayonnaise and Mayo-phobia: Why do some people hate mayonnaise so much?
    3. On the Etymology of the Word Mayonnaise
  4. For a fine collection of Bovril nonsense, this is the place.

huffduffer icon   Huffduff it

Filed under: Podcasts
See also:

6 thoughts on Mistaken about mayonnaise — and many other foods Food history and alternative realities

  • Jeremy Cherfas mentioned this post 5 years ago.

    I am extremely grateful to Tom Nealon for giving me a reason this year not to republish my previous podcasts about turkey and Thanksgiving. He has written a choice round-up of many things turkey that is bound to lift the gloom that sometimes hangs over leftovers.

    Who hasn’t spent Thanksgiving deep in self-recrimination for ruining the turkey that they spent all day lovingly basting? Cursing its very existence, making pale lumpy gravy, doubling down on the horror and shame? How many doomed holiday seasons have been kicked off with a dry turkey, bad stuffing, shitty mashed potatoes? Who among us hasn’t been rendered impotent by too much dry turkey — rendered incapable by tryptophan, bourbon and self-loathing. But the Aztecs knew something that we don’t — they had a turkey secret…

    That secret, and many more, in Tom’s piece.
    I know, too, as a solo podcaster, that I must not ignore this opportunity for self-promotion (or marketing) so:

    Tom Nealon’s podcast here: Mistaken about mayonnaise — and many other foods

    My first crack at the topic: A partial history of the turkey

    Further and better particulars: Another helping of turkey

    The icing on the cake (a metaphor too far): What a bunch of turkeys

    As for our celebrations, for the second year in a row we went with beef cheeks stracotto, and all present agreed: All Hail a new Thanksgiving tradition.
    Photograph by Don DeBold.

  • AgroBioDiverse commented 7 years ago.

    Listen to @pazzobooks talking about this and other untrodden alleyways of food history. eatthispodcast.com/mistaken-about… twitter.com/HowStuffWorks/…

  • ken commented 8 years ago.

    make up more fakelore to replace the old?

  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Webmentions

    Webmentions allow you to respond on your own site and have that appear here. Your response should include a link to this post. Paste the URL to your post below and your comment will appear here. (Learn More.)

Help Keep the Lights On

Ratings and reviews are great. So is an actual donation.

Elsewhere

There are other places I write and respond.

Our Daily Bread

Our Daily Bread was a series of micro-episodes on the history of wheat and bread, with an episode every day through the month of August 2018.

Posts are in correct chronological order, so you need to scroll to the bottom to find the latest.